They say, “If a hero lives long enough, they become the villain.” But what happens when the “victims” we empathize with reveal their darker sides? These ten individuals, initially seen as victims, later shocked the world by emerging as perpetrators—sometimes of unthinkable crimes. Were they victims turned villains, or villains all along?
1. Christopher Lee Watts
Watts garnered public sympathy after tearfully pleading for the safe return of his wife and two daughters. However, the horrifying truth came to light—he had murdered his entire family. His deceit earned him five life sentences.
2. Susan Smith
In 1994, Smith claimed her two toddlers were abducted during a carjacking. For days, her tearful pleas dominated the news. The chilling truth? She deliberately let her car roll into a lake, drowning her sons.
3. Tawana Brawley
At just 15 years old, Tawana Brawley captured national attention in 1987 with claims of a brutal assault by a group of white men. A grand jury later determined her allegations were a hoax, tarnishing reputations and sparking controversy.
4. Susan Mize
Susan Mize, a 17-year-old aspiring model, orchestrated a carjacking in 2018, using her male friend as bait. After staging the crime, she was arrested, lost her modeling career, and received a seven-year prison sentence.
5. Corey Harris
Corey Harris initially seemed like a victim of legal oversight when jailed for driving on a suspended license. However, it was revealed he had never held a valid license in any state. His repeated dishonesty unraveled his victim narrative.
6. Carolyn Bryant
Bryant falsely accused 14-year-old Emmett Till of harassing her in 1955, an accusation that led to his brutal lynching. Decades later, her role in the tragedy remained a haunting example of weaponized lies.
7. Karla Leanne Homolka
Homolka, one-half of the “Barbie and Ken Killers,” initially presented herself as a victim of Paul Bernardo’s abuse. However, videotapes revealed her active participation in his heinous crimes, including the murder of her sister. While Bernardo remains in prison, Homolka was released and controversially allowed to work near children.
8. Bethany Storro
Storro claimed to be the victim of a racially motivated acid attack in 2010, but the truth was far more unsettling. She had self-inflicted the injuries during a failed suicide attempt, later admitting she sought attention to spread her religious message.
9. Hellena Taylor
Known as the voice of Bayonetta, Taylor stirred controversy by accusing developers of offering her an offensively low fee for the third game in the series. She called for a boycott, but further revelations suggested she misrepresented the offer and demanded exorbitant compensation.
10. Mick Philpott
Philpott staged a fire at his home to frame his ex-wife as dangerous and portray himself as a hero. Tragically, the fire claimed the lives of his six children. His initial victim narrative crumbled as investigators uncovered his sinister plot.
These individuals remind us of the complexities behind the stories we hear. While some may initially seem like victims deserving of empathy, their actions often reveal deeper truths that challenge our perceptions.